Hearing #02
Pirate (Beneteau Moorings 405 - USA 25664) vs Intangible (Tartan 3700 - USA 52239), Zella (C&C 35 Mk III - USA 84044), Jasmin (Dufour 405 - USA 60455), Relentless (Schock 40 - USA 56565), Liberté (Beneteau 41.1 - USA 61284), NorthStar (Tartan 4000 - USA 61048), Elixir (Catalina 400 Deep Keel - USA 37), Vno (Jeanneau 40 Sun Odyssey SD - USA 60819), Sufficient Reason (Swan 42 - USA 4215), Baby Blue (Bieker Riptide 30 - USA 61470)
Hearing Type: protest
Hearing Status: withdrawn
Initiated By: John Demers
Respondent(s)
Intangible (Tartan 3700 - USA 52239)
Informed by hailing: No
Informed by displaying red flag: No
Informed by other method: No
Zella (C&C 35 Mk III - USA 84044)
Informed by hailing: No
Informed by displaying red flag: No
Informed by other method: No
Jasmin (Dufour 405 - USA 60455)
Informed by hailing: No
Informed by displaying red flag: No
Informed by other method: No
Relentless (Schock 40 - USA 56565)
Informed by hailing: No
Informed by displaying red flag: No
Informed by other method: No
Liberté (Beneteau 41.1 - USA 61284)
Informed by hailing: No
Informed by displaying red flag: No
Informed by other method: No
NorthStar (Tartan 4000 - USA 61048)
Informed by hailing: No
Informed by displaying red flag: No
Informed by other method: No
Elixir (Catalina 400 Deep Keel - USA 37)
Informed by hailing: No
Informed by displaying red flag: No
Informed by other method: No
Vno (Jeanneau 40 Sun Odyssey SD - USA 60819)
Informed by hailing: No
Informed by displaying red flag: No
Informed by other method: No
Sufficient Reason (Swan 42 - USA 4215)
Informed by hailing: No
Informed by displaying red flag: No
Informed by other method: No
Baby Blue (Bieker Riptide 30 - USA 61470)
Informed by hailing: No
Informed by displaying red flag: No
Informed by other method: No
The Incident
When / Where: The incident(s) occurred between 5:20 am and and 6:00 am, on Monday morning, July 24, 2023, North of Grays Reef Passage.
Description: The listed vessels of protest were visually and via GPS/AIS tracking observed to round Buoy #1 instead of the required New Shoal Lighted Bell Buoy #3 (2023-LL No. 17745) to starboard as listed in Section 11. Course and Marks.
Rules Alleged Broken: Failed to follow the Sailing Instructions requirement for specific Race Course marks.
THIS PROTEST HAS BEEN WITHDRAWN
Witnesses
-
No witnesses
Files
-
No files uploaded
Validity
Objection To Jury: Yes
Incident Identified: Yes
Red Flag Displayed: Yes
Within Time Limit: Yes
Proper Hail: Yes
Is Valid: Yes
Procedural Matters
PROTEST WITHDRAWN
Facts Found
PROTEST WITHDRAWN
Conclusions
PROTEST WITHDRAWN
Decision
PROTEST WITHDRAWN
Reason
PROTEST WITHDRAWN